Butler Street Starters

Crab Stuffed Mushroom Caps

Our House Specialty! Crab stuffing, garlic butter and melted Mozzarella cheese - 14

 

Butler Wings

Served Buffalo style, BBQ or plain - 14

 

Baked Spinach and Artichoke Dip

Our house made spinach and artichoke dip served

with warm flatbread - 12

 

Drunken Mussels

P.E.I mussels steamed in white wine and garlic with roasted tomatoes and red onion. Served with garlic crostini - 13

 

Boom Boom Shrimp

Fried shrimp tossed in Boom Boom sauce - 12

 

Shrimp Cocktail

Jumbo Shrimp chilled and served with our zesty

cocktail sauce - 13

 

Crab Stuffed Shrimp

Jumbo Shrimp topped with crab stuffing, garlic butter and melted Mozzarella cheese - 15 

​

Crab Cakes

Served with Butler Remoulade - 15 

​

Pub Pretzel Bites & Beer Cheese - 11

 

Honey Sriracha Brussels Sprouts

Flash fried and tossed in a honey sriracha sauce - 10

 

Chips, Salsa and Guacamole - 8

Ward Room Entrees

Entrees are served with potato or vegetable unless otherwise stated.

Add a house salad or cup of soup for 3. 

Add a small Caesar salad or bowl or soup for 4.  

​

Dress Up Your Steak!

Add Balsamic Button Mushrooms 2 

Grilled Onions 2  -  Crumbled Bleu Cheese 2

Onion Tanglers 2  - Grilled or Fried Shrimp 8

Crab Cakes 5  -  6 oz. Lobster Tail 18

​

8 oz. Top Sirloin

Chargrilled to you preference - 17

​

House Cut Angus Ribeye

12-14 oz. Marbled and full of flavor - 25

 

Crab Mushroom Chicken

Baked chicken breast topped with a blend of

crab meat and shrimp, mushrooms and melted

Mozzarella cheese - 17

 

Surf & Turf

8 oz. Top Sirloin paired with a 6 oz. lobster tail served with drawn butter - 32

 

Pan Fried Walleye

A Butler Specialty! Pan Fried golden brown and served with tartar sauce and a lemon - 23

​

Gorgonzola Penne Pasta

Gorgonzola cream sauce, mushroom, onion and roasted tomatoes served over penne pasta - 14

With Grilled Blackened Chicken - 19

With Grilled Blackened Shrimp - 22

With Blackened Top Sirloin - 24

 

Chardonnay Spinach Salmon

Grilled Atlantic Salmon over a bed of sauteed spinach topped with a Chardonnay cream sauce and roasted tomatoes - 23

​

Lobster Mac & Cheese

Oven baked White Cheddar mac & cheese tossed with lobster meat and topped with bread crumbs. Served with garlic toast - 17

 

​

 

Our Famous Butler Burger

Grilled ham, American cheese, lettuce and

mayonnaise - 12

 

Pub Burger

Win Schuler’s Bar Cheese, beer steamed onions and bacon, served on a grilled pretzel bun - 12

 

Patty Melt

Swiss cheese and grilled onions served on

grilled marbled rye - 12

 

Maple Bacon Waffle Burger 

Cheddar cheese, bacon, onion tanglers,

and a maple bacon glaze.

Served open faced on a sugar pearl waffle - 12

 

Steakhouse Burger

Seasoned with steak seasoning and Worcestershire sauce. Topped with Bleu cheese, grilled mushrooms and

onion tanglers - 12

 

​

 

Horseradish Peppercorn Burger

Pepper jack cheese, A1 Sauce, bacon, lettuce, tomato and a horseradish peppercorn sauce topped with onion tanglers. Served on a grilled pretzel bun - 12

​

Goat Cheese Burger 

Goat cheese, roasted tomatoes, artichoke hearts, pesto aioli and lettuce - 12

 

Swiss Mushroom Burger

Grilled mushrooms and Swiss cheese - 12

 

Olive Burger

House made green olive sauce and lettuce - 11

​

Cheeseburger

Your choice of American, Swiss, Cheddar,

Pepper Jack, Smoked Gouda or Bleu cheese

with your choice of condiments - 11

​

Beyond Cheeseburger

Plant based Beyond Meat patty with your choice of

American, Swiss, Cheddar, Pepper Jack,

Smoked Gouda or Bleu Cheese with your choice of condiments. Served on a French Roll - 14

​

​

 

Harbor Side Sandwiches 

Starboard Sides

Your Choice of:

 

House Cut Butler Fries

Small - 3  Large - 6

 

Beer Battered French Fries

Small - 3  Large - 6

 

Beer Battered Onion Rings

Small - 3  Large - 6

 

Sweet Potato Fries

Small - 3  Large - 6

 

Baked Potato - 3

 

Red Skin Mashed Potatoes - 3

 

Seasonal Vegetable - 3

 

Coleslaw - 3

 

​

Reuben

Your choice of corned beef or turkey with Swiss cheese and sauerkraut on grilled marbled rye. A Butler Classic! - 12

 

California Chicken Club

Grilled chicken, Swiss cheese, guacamole, bacon, lettuce tomato. Served on a Brioche bun - 12

 

Smoked Gouda Grilled Cheese

Melted smoked Gouda cheese, roasted tomatoes, artichoke hearts and grilled mushrooms on grilled

multi grain bread - 11

 

Quesadilla

Seasoned chicken, black beans, corn, onions, bell peppers, Colby Jack and Mozzarella cheese melted in a flour tortilla. Served with salsa and sour cream - 13

​

Grilled Flatbread Turkey Club

Turkey, bacon, cheddar and Swiss cheese, served deluxe and folded in grilled flatbread - 12

 

Lobster Grilled Cheese

Melted Mozzarella, langostinos, kale blend on grilled multigrain bread - 13

 

Grilled Atlantic Salmon B.L.T

Grilled salmon fillet, bacon, lettuce, tomato

and a pesto aioli topped with a balsamic glaze.

Served on a brioche roll - 13

​

Beer Battered Perch Sandwich

Lightly battered and fried. Served on a brioche roll with tartar sauce and lettuce - 14

​

Pot Roast Sandwich

Slow roasted pot roast, Smoked Gouda cheese, beer steamed onions and horseradish cream sauce.

Served on a French roll - 12

​