Appetizers,  Soups & Salads

Peel and Eat Shrimp

Half pound of chilled shrimp served with

our zesty cocktail sauce - 16


Butler Wings

Served Buffalo style, BBQ or plain - 16


Boom Boom Shrimp

Fried shrimp tossed in Boom Boom sauce - 15 

Pub Pretzel Bites, Beer Cheese and Pub Mustard - 13


Pita Chips & Dip

House made pita chips with your choice of dip - 11

~Butler Spinach and Artichoke Dip

~Fiesty Feta Hummus

~Win Schuler's Bar Cheese

~Smoked Whitefish Dip

Chips, Salsa & Guacamole - 11


Butler Clam Chowder 

 Bowl  7

House Salad

Mixed greens, tomato, cucumber, red onion and edamame. 

Small - 6     Large - 12


Cherry Chicken and Walnut Salad

Romaine topped with grilled chicken breast, dried cherries, walnuts, Bleu cheese and red onion.

Served with a Cherry Vinaigrette.  - 15

Southwest Chicken Salad

Romaine topped with seasoned chicken breast, corn, black beans, tomato, guacamole, onion, Colby Jack cheese and tortilla chips. Served with roasted poblano vinaigrette dressing. - 15



All burgers are ½ lb. fresh ground Angus sirloin and may be charbroiled to your preference.

Burgers are served on a sesame seed bun with potato chips and a pickle, unless stated otherwise.

Substitute a BEYOND BURGER patty for any burger ADD -3 

Add French Fries or Onion Rings – 3

Our Famous Butler Burger

Grilled ham, American cheese, lettuce and

mayonnaise - 14

Paradise Burger

Cheddar cheese, grilled pineapple, shredded coconut, lettuce and sweet habanero mayonnaise - 14


Tuscon Burger

Seasoned burger patty, Pepper Jack cheese, bacon, lettuce and chipotle maynnoaise - 14



Horseradish Peppercorn Burger

Pepper Jack cheese, A1 Sauce, bacon, lettuce, tomato

and a horseradish peppercorn sauce topped with

onion tanglers. - 14


Your choice of American, Swiss, Cheddar,

Pepper Jack, or Bleu cheese

with your choice of condiments - 13


All sandwiches are served with chips and a pickle, unless otherwise stated.

Add French Fries or Onion Rings - 3

Boom Boom Shrimp Tacos

Fried shrimp tossed in Boom Boom Sauce, served in flour tortillas with lettuce, tomato and Colby Jack cheese.

Served with tortilla chips and salsa. - 15


California Chicken Club

Grilled chicken, Swiss cheese, guacamole, bacon, lettuce and tomato. Served on a French roll. - 14


Beer Battered Perch Sandwich

Lightly battered and fried. Served pm a brioche roll with tartar sauce and lettuce - 13



8 oz. Wagyu Sizzler

Served with French Fries - 23


Lake Perch Basket

Lightly dusted and fried. Served with French and coleslaw - 18


Chicken Tender Basket

Lightly breaded and golden fried, served with French Fries and coleslaw - 15

*Ask your server about menu items that are cooked to order or served raw. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness

Signature Cocktails

Wine By The Glass

Bloody Mary

Our special blend of secret ingredients makes

this the best around! 


Singapore Yacht Tail 

Our award winning Bloody Mary made with Absolut Peppar and topped with chilled shrimp


Butler Rum Runner

Bacardi Rum, Captain Morgan Rum, Coconut rum, pineapple juice and a splash of grenadine 

Butler Mule

Titos Vodka, ginger beer, lime juice and

fresh squeezed lime


Ultimate Margarita

Premium Gold Tequila, Triple Sec, margarita mix. Topped with a floater of Grand Marnier 

Oval Beach Tea

Citrus Vodka, Raspberry Vodka, Coconut Vodka Peachtree Schnapps, cranberry juice and pineapple juice

Lazy Day

Pineapple Rum, orange juice, pineapple juice

and a splash of grenadine

Blueberry Lemonade

New Holland Knickerbocker Blueberry Gin and Lemonade


Strawberry Mojito

Bacardi Rum, fresh mint, simple syrup, soda water and house made strawberry puree


Tropical Punch 

Coconut Vodka, Pineapple Vodka, cranberry juice and a splash of sour mix 

Mezzacorona Pinot Grigio - 7

Haymaaker Sauvignon Blanc - 7

Mezzacorona Chardonnay - 7

Mezzacorona Rose - 7

Mezzacorona Merlot - 7

Mezzacorona Cabernet - 7


Wine By The Bottle

Francis Ford Coppola Rose - 28

Whitehaven Sauvignon Blanc - 36

Kendal Jackson Chardonnay - 36

Cakebread Chardonnary - 58

Meiomi Pinot Noir - 36

J Lohr Cabernet - 32

Duckhorn Cabernet - 65


Canned Beer


Corona Premier

Bells Oberon

Bells Two Hearted

Miller Lite


Bud Light

Coors Light

SBC Oval Beach Blonde

SBC Blueberry Lemonade Shandy

Cranes Hard Cider

White Claw Hard Seltzer

High Noon Hard Seltzer


The Butler - COVID-19 Guidelines

Frozen Drinks

Pina Colada

Bacardi Rum, pineapple juice and

Island Oasis Pina Colada Mix 


Stawberry Daquiri

Bacardi Rum and Island Oasis Strawberry Mix


Key Lime Colada

KeKe Key Lime Liquor and Island Oasis Pina Colada Mix 

Lake Effect

Coconut Rum, Blue Curaco, pineapple juice and Island Oasis Pina Colada Mix


Strawberry Margarita

Tequila, Triple Sec, and Island Oasis Strawberry Mix

Peanut Butter Banana Split

Screwball Peanut Butter Whisky, chocolate liqueur and Island Oasis Banana Mix

Welcome Back! We are happy to have you here with us and we are ready to serve you again. We are doing everything we can to ensure your safety as well as all of our employees by following the strict guidelines and regulations set in place by the CDC, State and County Health Departments and the Governors orders. With that being said things will be a little different. Here are some of the procedures you can expect from us along with some rules we will be expecting you to follow. 

  • Please do not enter our building if you or anyone in your house are, or have been recently sick. We are monitoring all of our employees and delivery personnel daily. 

  • Limit your party to 8 people or less. 

  • Please ONE transaction per table to limit contact. 

  • Do not move or combine tables. They are configured in accordance with social distancing guidelines. 

  • Our seating capacity has been reduced to 50% in order to maintain 6 foot distancing between tables. 

  • This means wait times will be longer so please be patient. We are doing the best to accommodate every one of you.

  • Out of respect for waiting guests, we ask our seated guests to limit visits to 1 1/2 hours. 

  • Do not enter our building until you have received a text letting you know your table is ready. We no longer have a waiting area, so please either wait in your car of take a walk around our beautiful town. 

  • No Loitering on our porch or away from/around you table. PLEASE maintain 6 foot social distancing guidelines from all other guests. 

  • Face coverings are required when you enter the building and until you are seated at your table. 

  • If possible please view our menu from our website,, or scan our QR Code on your phone. If you are not able to do so we can provide you with a disposable menu upon request. 

  • Bar stools have been removed to maintain 6 foot distancing. Please no loitering around the bar. 

  • We will have single serve salt & pepper available upon request. Condiment bottles will be brought to the table upon request and thoroughly sanitized between each use. Silverware will be rolled using single-use gloves. 

  • Our staff if required to wear masks at all times. All kitchen employees will be wearing gloves in the kitchen area when handling food, consistent with the guidelines and regulations from the CDC and Health Department. 

  • Each shift will have a designated cleaner to clean, disinfect and sanitize work surfaces, shared surfaces and bathroom surfaces. 


Please be kind, understanding and patient as we all work through these changes together. 

Thank You!

The Butler Staff